Quick answer: the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream comes closest to the Aveeno Calm + Restore Triple Oat Hydrating Moisturizer: it shares all of its hero actives (Colloidal Oatmeal). On price, the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream actually costs more (Mid-range versus Budget). It also overlaps with 3 other products below.
Products the Ultra Repair Cream matches
1 of 1
hero active matched
Cheaper originalColloidal Oatmeal
Why it holds up: Shares all of the original's hero actives: Colloidal Oatmeal.
Full ingredient analysis →See them side by side →2 of 3
hero actives matched
Pricier originalCeramidesShea Butter
Why it holds up: Shares Ceramides and Shea Butter, but not Panthenol.
Full ingredient analysis →See them side by side →La Roche-Posay
1 of 3
hero actives matched
Same price tierShea Butter
Why it holds up: Shares Shea Butter, but not Panthenol and Madecassoside.
Full ingredient analysis →See them side by side →2 of 3
hero actives matched
Pricier originalCeramidesShea Butter
The catch: Only shares supporting ingredients (Ceramides and Shea Butter). It doesn't contain the original's Peptides, so it won't do the same job.
Full ingredient analysis →See them side by side →Common questions
Is the First Aid Beauty Ultra Repair Cream a real dupe?
It shares hero actives with 4 same-category products in our catalogue, most closely the Aveeno Calm + Restore Triple Oat Hydrating Moisturizer (matching 1 of 1 of its hero actives). "Dupe" here means shared key ingredients, not an identical formula.
Does matching more hero actives make it better?
No. The match count only shows how many hero actives are shared. The base, supporting ingredients, texture and price still differ, so use the side-by-side comparison for the full picture.
Educational information only — not medical advice. Overlap reflects shared hero actives, not clinical equivalence.